What do you get the person who has everything? That’s the conundrum many of us find ourselves in when searching for the perfect gift for our in-laws. (Just imagine Meghan Markle having to go through her holiday shopping list!) Instead of being predictable and buying yet another candle or tie, we decided to ask Annabelle Moehlmann, founder of the insanely chic online shopping destination Land of Belle, for her expert advice of how to gift to impress.

Below, her picks on what someone should get every member of their new family.